D. Caries Essay, Research Paper
Caries have been a constant nuisance to humans, decaying teeth can become a major problem for those affected. It is certainly not the oldest pathology, nor the one of the greatest prevalence throughout humankind, but the information that can be extrapolate from such pathologies is great. The aim of this paper is to outline the pathology of caries and the influence that these have had on the human populations affected. Caries or caries dentium is the common name for tooth decay. It is a local disease, which is characterized by an irreversible and permanent destruction of the tooth hard tissue, enamel. Thus spreads the destruction to the rest of the tooth and, and possibly leading to tooth loss and possibly infections in other areas, more specifically through the maxillary or mandibular areas.
Also I have included some other defects that are import and not only to the observation of caries but overall pathologies and their implications for the individuals affected. In this paper I will attempt to outline the causes of this disease and some of the numerous factors that cause it, as many have a hand in the process. Also I will show how these changes were brought about and how these affected the individuals with caries.
To begin I will introduce the reader he to other defects that affect the same area and should be considered when any analysis of the area is to be understood. Any disturbance, such as severe infection can disrupt enamel formation. That disruption of enamel formation will leave an enduring record as a disorientation of enamel prisms. Because the human dental growth sequence is known, the age at which the enamel disturbance occurred can be determined from the location of the disturbance within the enamel. A standard chart for dental development can be consulted for this purpose. There is extensive literature (now in excess of 500 articles) on the epidemiology and etiology of enamel defects. Many of which have been investigations using laboratory animals
There are two types of enamel developmental disturbance of interest to the paleopathologist (1) Microdefects are histological structures known as Wilson bands. These are accentuated brown striae of Retzius. The most celebrated of these is the neontal line, reported by Schour in 1936 If the disturbance is short in duration and the enamel formation resumes, that disturbance is recorded as a narrow band seen in the section of enamel under a light microscope. That evidence of enamel formation disruption and recovery is called a Wilson band. Wilson bands are thin layers of abnormally structured enamel marking the position of the active ameoloblasts at the time of insult. Wilson bands are sometimes called’pathological brown striae’ in the literature. This descriptive term is a nice way to describe the bands, which contain ’sudden changes in prism direction associated with atypical rod forms.’ Wide neonatal lines are associated with traumatic births. Wilson bands appear to represent brief periods of stress lasting from one to five days.
The examination of teeth for histological disturbance is destructive; therefore, this technique is not used of rare ancient hominid teeth. 2) Macrodefects are defects visible on the tooth surface. They are known as hypoplasias. These can vary in appearance from small pits or furrows to large, deep grooves or even large areas of missing enamel. Typically these defects are horizontal grooves that are called chronological or linear (enamel hypoplasias. They seem to reflect impairment of enamel formation for weeks or months, while Wilson lines record events limited to one or a few days. If the enamel formation does not resume, the defect can be viewed macroscopically as a transverse area of depressed enamel, this is known as enamel hypoplasia, Enamel hypoplasias show a predilection for anterior teeth and for the cervical and middle thirds of tooth crowns. Investigators have shown statistical associations between enamel hypoplasias and a variety of clinical conditions of which we will only mention a few here: premature birth, malnutrition, fluorosis, high fever, localized trauma and systemic metabolic distress such as gastrointestinal disorders.
Dental plaque is a mixed microbial biofilm growing on teeth and is the prime aetiological agent of the two main oral diseases, dental caries and periodontal disease. The microbial composition of plaque varies between individuals and the location on the tooth and generally reflects the complex nature of the ecology of the mouth.
In common with other biofilms, the microbial composition of dental plaque is capable of change in response to changes in the environment, notably the diet. These responses are modulated by homeostatic mechanisms inherent in the plaque in ways, which are as yet poorly understood.
The major sites of plaque accumulation are in the fissures of molar teeth, in the area bounded by margin of the gum and the tooth and between adjacent the teeth. In addition, plaque can cause gingival inflammation, which may result in loss of epithelial attachment to the tooth leading to the formation of sub-gingival pockets (Frayer 1989). These pockets may also harbor dental plaque which is significantly different from supra-gingival plaque in a number of important respects in particular a much lower redox potential which selects for a variety of anaerobic bacterial species.
Although dental plaque varies considerably in composition, it has been possible to piece together a sequence of events, which lead to its establishment. The consensus view of plaque development begins with a clean tooth surface covered by a conditioning film of salivary proteins and glycoproteins, called the tooth pellicle, being colonized by so-called “pioneer species”(Larson 1995). These multiply forming first a monolayer and, subsequently, palisades of cells perpendicular to the tooth surface. During and after this outgrowth period secondary colonization by a variety of Gram positive and negative species occurs leading to a large increase in the species diversity. Foremost among the events contributing to this secondary colonization is the process known as co-aggregation whereby colonizing microbes attach to cells already part of the developing biofilm(Moore and Colbett, 1983:140). This allows species which can not attach, or can attach only poorly, to the tooth pellicle to participate in the biofilm. At 24 hours the maturing dental plaque contains a wide variety of bacteria and it is possible to detect easily identifiable inter-species associations such as the well documented”corn-cob-configurations”(Frayer, 1989), although a wide variety of other inter-species associations will be present.
Further colonization and growth of established bacteria takes place as the plaque matures to form a stable, climax community. This pattern of development leading to a climax community has been termed “bacterial succession”. The resulting community consists of individual microbes and microcolonies acting in complex consortia, which can convey a range of beneficial properties. These include feeding synergies, improved antibiotic resistance and a host of cooperative mechanisms, which are the subject of much current research.
The Carious process
As mentioned before dental plaque is a deposit on the teeth consisting of food debris together with various components derived from the saliva. Within this plaque dwell bacteria, when these bacteria metabolize carbohydrates they produce acid waste products. It is the dissolution of the dental hard tissues by these acids that cause carries. Dietary sucrose changes both the thickness and the chemical nature of plaque. Mutans streptococci and some other plaque bacteria use the monosaccharide components (glucose and fructose) and the energy of the disaccharide bond of sucrose to assemble extracellular polysaccharides. These increase the thickness of plaque substantially, and also change the chemical nature of its extracellular space from liquid to gel. The gel limits movement of some ions. Thick gel-plaque allows the development of an acid environment against the tooth surface, protected from salivary buffering. Plaque, which has not had contact with sucrose, is both thinner and better buffered. A diet with a high proportion of sucrose therefore increases caries risk. Thicker plaque occurs in pits and fissures, just beneath the contact area and, in patients with poor oral hygiene, near the gingival margin. The initial area of lesion in caries consists of first, a softened, which then progresses into a small hole or caries in the enamel surface. As this process continues there is a widening of this deterioration and a caries is formed.
When this reaches the dento enamel surface the destruction tends to spread latterly due to a typical increase in organic material within the affected area, which is to be expected as living individuals would undoubtedly continue to consume food and thus continue to produce saliva. This process will eventually undermine the enamel crown leaving a fragile hollow cavity which can collapse due to the stresses that are present, weather they be from eating, use as a tool or any other type of trauma that would place stress upon the subject teeth (Shafer 1983:432)
In this way caries may lead to a complete destruction of an enamel crown. Due to this destruction infection of the pulp may occur, either through direct exposure to the oral environment or via opened exposed dentinal tubules (Hilson 1986: 316) This infection in the pulp cavity may lead to the formation of a dental abbess at the tooth socket by way of the root canal. Thus the presence of a dental abbess on skeletal remains and the interpretation for those situations where the tooth may not be present in the burial environment there can still be some extrapolation of carious evidence.
Also it is important to mention that untreated caries ca give rise to potentially lethal complications (Mays 1998:148) Advanced caries of a maxillary tooth can lead to and cause complications, including infections that can spread to vital organs, and possibly lead to death. Each time that plaque bacteria come into contact with food or drink containing simple sugars (monosaccharides such as glucose and fructose, and disaccharides such as sucrose, lactose and maltose) they use them for their metabolic needs, making organic acids as a metabolic by-product. If these acids are not buffered by saliva they dissolve the surface of the apatite crystals of adjacent tooth structure. This is called demineralization. In thick gel-plaque the pH falls within seconds of contact with dietary sugars, and it can stay low for up to 2 hours. When the pH is neutral the same crystals can re-grow, using calcium, phosphate and fluoride from saliva. This is called remineralization. Caries begins and progresses when demineralization outweighs remineralization. Caries therefore depends on the balance between demineralization and remineralization, i.e. on the frequency of eating (and on the microbial composition of the plaque and its chemical nature and thickness, on the local fluoride concentration and on the buffering capacity of saliva). A frequent pattern of eating therefore increases caries risk.
Diet and Environment.
The breakdown of enamel by the bacterial processes mentioned earlier is most commonly associated with that of carbohydrate food residue present within the mouth. Foods such as fats oils and meats including fish, are non- cariogenic (Shaw: 1954) and the protean residues responsible for caries (Becks et al. 1944; Dreizen and Spies 1948) are in some cases inhibited by a diet made up mainly of these foods. Whereas a diet consisting mainly of carbohydrates will significantly increase the incidence of dental caries. (Pederson:1947)
The most cariogenic carbohydrates are those of a low molecular weight such as sugars, these are very readily metabolized by bacteria to produce acid by-products. Thus there would be a correlation between sweet sugary foods and the incidence of dental caries, this has been shown in the archaeological record. One of the most profound changes to occur with the foraging to farming transition was the widespread decline in oral health, which was almost certainly tied to increased consumption of plant carbohydrates. Especially obvious is the remarkable increase in dental caries wherever and whenever the transition occurred. Dental caries is a disease process characterized by focal demineralization of dental hard tissues by organic acids produced by bacterial fermentation of dietary carbohydrates, especially sugars (Larsen, 1997). Dental caries are manifested as pits (or cavities) in teeth, ranging in size from barely discernible discoloration of enamel to large cavitations or substantial loss of crown matter (Figure 1).
Comparisons of foragers and farmers globally reveal a consistent pattern of increase in frequency of carious lesions (Larsen, 1995). Eastern North America offers an important perspective on the impact of increased carbohydrate consumption on humans, especially because so many dental samples have been studied in this region. Figure 2 shows the comparison of prehistoric populations lacking maize (Archaic, Early Woodland), some use of maize (Middle Woodland), and dependence on maize (Late Woodland, Mississippian, Contact) for the region. The contrast between foragers and farmers is striking.
One of the important indicators of periodontal disease in skeletal remains is antemortem tooth loss (Figure 3). Periodontal disease results in a weakening of the alveolar bone supporting the dental structures, and as the bone resorbs, teeth loosen and are exfoliated. Although the evidence is not as overwhelming as dental caries, there is a pattern of increase in antemortem loss that corresponds with cariogenesis in agricultural populations from diverse settings, such as Nubia, eastern North America, western Europe, and south Asia (reviewed in Larsen, 1995).
Another example, in Britain there were only small amounts or sugar cane available until large scale imports from the New World became available. But by the seventeenth century the imports from the colonies were in full swing and sugar was being imported at a fantastic rate. These imports coincided with a greater occurrence of caries where by the early years of the twentieth century, caries in England had increased three fold in since the Iron Age In Britain (Mays: 1998; 151)
Also starches are a major dietary carbohydrate, which if left in a environment such as the mouth can breakdown and start to deteriorate the enamel, but still not quite as much as the high incidence as with that of high levels of a sucrose diet. Frayer (1989) using archaeological evidence from the early upper Paleolithic to the late Mesolithic associated an increase in caries associated with a changing environment and thus a changing subsistence for those inhabitants. He proved that sites dating to the early upper Paleolithic had a supriseingly low incidence of caries, where environmental factors did not foster extensive plant grow. In contrast late upper Paleolithic sites show a marked warming of climate where there is an increase in the growth of plant material and plant foods. This change would have promoted a growth in subsistence farming, at the very least. This would have increased the amount of plant carbohydrates and thus there was an increase in the occurrence in evidence of caries.
Again in the Mesolithic there is further warming in the surrounding climate to the point where an even greater amount of plant food harvest is attainable for human consumption. Frayer found that for the Mesolithic, there was a negative correlation between rates of caries and latitude. This was the case where skeletal assemblages from northern sites continually show a decrease in caries, where those of southern sites bring with it a marked increase. As opposed to those from the later upper Paleolithic and even those of slightly northern Mesolithic, the implications of this are obvious with regards to the interpretation of climate and substance.
Coarse diets, as consumed by earlier groups of peoples were a natural way of reducing the incidence of dental caries, as the rough foods consumed tends to scour the teeth free of food debris and thus preventing the build-up of dental plaque. Also with the diet effecting the frequency of caries on teeth it can also effect the location of these caries. The reasons for this include for example, within western populations there is a very soft diet. This again does not allow for a cleaning of the pits and fishers, therefore a natural cleaning process is eliminated, leaving a high amount of caries on the occusal surfaces.
Among Prehistoric populations there is a greater incidence of caries within a female section in most populations that have been studied. This raises the question why this difference, and what are the causes and are these differences physiological or behavioral? It is possible that the age of an individual can play a factor with regards to the occurrence of dental caries. It is generally accepted that in most populations women tend to live slightly longer lives than that of men within their respective groups. Thus there would be a greater exposure to the process that would cause caries to form. Also the point that female dentition erupt occurs earlier that that of their male counterparts they are again exposed to carious producing factors (Dunbar 1969).
At this point in this paper I believe that I have shown conclusively that there is a direct correlation between the move to agricultural movements within human population, so now I will show how this effected the differences in gender and caries. One such explanation relies heavily on a behavioral explanation. One such explanation shows evidence from the New World where pre contact Native Americans had just such a complex. Larson, Griffin and Shavit (1991) theorize that the division in labor in agricultural societies is a major impetus for this difference. They propose that a female was responsible for planting, plant care and gathering, whereas a male was responsible for hunting and the collection of fauna. Therefore although men would have been exposed to a greater percentage, as opposed to those of past to plant foods within their diet, women would have had the greatest exposure and the incidence of ingestion of these plant foods would be greater. So inevitably the occurrence of dental caries would have a greater impact on the dental health of females within this group.
Again these same authors contend another area of behavior that might have influenced this complex. Their conclusion is that there is a difference in the pattern and frequency in the eating habits of such individuals. They contend females would have had a greater contact with these plant foods, where an irregular eating pattern would have been employed thus the number of time, where meals occur is greater. Whereas men would not have been eating smaller more frequent meals, rather the opposite where there would have been larger more regular meals (Frayer, 1989). And if these individuals were on a sustained hunt than there would have been a less that average exposure to cariogenic foods. Therefore social roles might have played a significant role into the introduction of caries into the everyday life of early agriculturists.
Caries are a very ancient and widespread decease, it has been found that as far back as Australopithecine of south Africa had even been affected (Robinson 1952:Clement 1956), as well Homo erectus (Brodreck 1948). In the Neanderthals of Mount Carmel/Palestine was as common place as in the upper Paleolithic. This said caries were, and are not exclusive to Humans, modern apes were affected and as far back as Pliocene animals and Pleistocene mammals. Caries are also present in domesticated animals especially when infected with Sheptococcus mutans (Brothwell 1980)
According to current knowledge the rate of caries increased exorbitantly with the switch from Hunter Gather, to the Neolithic when food became rich in carbohydrates, which has increased over time.
The frequency of dental caries in a skeletal collection can be expressed in a number of ways; a paleopathologist could score caries as absent or present in individual skeletons. Then us that data to express the proportion of the total number of skeletons that were examined. Inherently the problem of examination lies within the burial environment along with the individual. This problem is that teeth are not stable within there sockets, and archaeological or other excavations tend to facilitate the occurrence of their deposition, and eventual loss in the burial environment and through the subsequent excavations. The inherent process of intrusion that these excavations cause, along with handling of these remains, during such possess as examination curation and cleaning. Also these problems surface within the burial environment where an acidic matrix may cause a premature deterioration and thus a loss if vital information, especially if there is only a partial loss of dentition where a lack of caries may be incorrectly interpreted. Other factor that can influence carious condition, include age, where an individuals exposure to conditions that cause caries is increased over time in an older individual. Another condition that effects the examination and interpretation is modern techniques, more specifically tooth extraction where the affected tooth is removed and the information is not gained by the investigator
How the disease has been treated in the past
During the historic period, the disease was thought to be gangrene of the teeth. Gangrene is death of part of the body. If left untreated, a gangrenous area increases in size until the afflicted individual became ill and died. Caries was treated as gangrene of other parts of the body was treated at that time, by surgical removal. Extraction was the equivalent of amputation for gangrenous limbs(Bremner, Maurice David Kaufman, 1975). The surgical specialty of dentistry developed because of the high demand for caries treatment by extraction. Extraction is physically difficult in young people with good periodontal health. However it was effective in eliminating the disease from an individual when all of the teeth had gone.
An alternative method of surgical removal, and a simpler one than extraction, was local debridement by cleaning out the decayed area. Many dentists advocated using a small file to abrade away approximal areas of teeth, including the area of the early lesion, to treat the disease. After the file was used the area was left open to saliva. This had some advantages because it was a simple treatment and the decay was slow to recur. But it also had the disadvantages that food tended to lodge between the teeth and the teeth tended to move over time. (Bremner, Maurice David Kaufman, 1975)
Local removal and then filling the resultant cavity was also attempted. The decay was removed with hand scrapers (’excavators) or rotating burs. The early filings sealed badly and tended to fail within months, or a few years at most, because of continuing decay.
Early fillings were metal – lead, tin or gold. Each of these metals could be pressed or hammered into the cavity. Pure gold was the most difficult of these metals to handle, but tended to last longer if it was very carefully placed and thoroughly condensed (Bremner, Maurice David Kaufman, 1975). Small bundles of very thin sheets of pure gold, called gold foil, were added one-by-one with tiny instruments and welded together using small hammers, called mallets. A mixture of silver and mercury, called dental amalgam, was also used to fill cavities. The mixture is initially soft, so it can be packed into the cavity with only moderate pressure and because of chemical reactions between the silver and mercury new compounds are formed and it becomes hard (Prinz, 1975).
. The concept that caries was gangrene continued well into the 20th Century, and many patterns of care which flow from that concept continue up to the present time. The fastidious and systematic refinement of cavity design and filling technologies in the early 1900’s, mainly through the work of dentists in North America, changed the nature of caries treatment (Prinz, 1975). Through this work the outcome of the restorative approach was improved until by mid-century it became preferable to extraction. Carefully placed restorations (which by mid-century included fillings, onlays and crowns) tended to leak less. It became commonplace for restorations to last several years before they failed through continuing decay (Bremner, Maurice David Kaufman, 1975).
Complete removal of carious enamel and dentin was thought to be an essential part of successful filling design. Restorative materials did not adhere to teeth. In order for them to stay in place decayed areas had to be modified in shape, with hand or rotary cutting instruments, to make retentive cavity forms. Cavity shapes were also modified to increase the strength of the tooth and restoration. Minimal sizes of cavities were also mandated, so that the junction between the filling and tooth wason areas of the tooth where caries did not usually begin, in the hope that this would result in restorations which would last longer before recurrent decay occurred. This was called ‘extension for prevention’. The act of making a restoration therefore usually involved the removal of substantial amount of tooth structure, often several times more than was actually decayed (Bremner, Maurice David Kaufman, 1975).
Preparing large cavities in hard tooth structure with hand cutting instruments (chisels, hatchets and hoes) was very slow and difficult, but it became easier as rotary cutting instruments (rotary burs) were developed and refined. By the 1970’s high-speed, air turbine-driven rotary cutting instruments became widely available. It became relatively easy to prepare large cavities using tungsten carbide burs and industrial diamond-impregnated rotary instruments.
With regard to prehistoric populations there is little evidence for dentistry other than the probability that troublesome teeth would have been extracted. Evidence would suggest that to stay the progress of a dental caries would require knowledge of the process involved. This is not to say that ancient peoples had no knowledge of this, but the simplest remedy would have been to remove it, and for someone with the means a prosthetic might have been used.
This pathology would not have carried the same social stigma that for example, Leprosy would have. Also the fact that the injury was concealed for the most part would have shielded the individual. The fact that any individual could have been affected from any socio-economic background would have lessened the impact. Although one could say that a person of greater means would have a greater exposure to the caries forming foods, where they probably would have had a softer diet.
Throughout history there has been evidence for the use of prosthetics, which suggests an extraction of troubled teeth and an attempt to conceal their loss. There is also the problem of eating. An individual who was affected with caries on their molars, to the point of causing great pain while chewing, would possibly have extracted the troublesome teeth and received dentures to facilitate the chewing process.
Caries serve as an important marker for the development of noting humankind’s changes, not only through time but through physiological and cultural changes. But the most important aspect of caries is its presence within all populations, and the changes that these populations encompassed into such things as their diet are reflected within the pathological record. However not every pit on dentition is caused by caries which can result in some misinterpretation with regards to the prevalence in populations, as caries can be visually observed without the aid of magnification instruments. Some defects may depend on genetics, for example the buccal pits on molars, where other examples could be influenced by burial matrix.
To understand the change that caries represent is important there is a significant implication for the occurrence of caries and human evolution. These changes serve as a marker with regards to not only a specific time period but to overall changes within peoples and how these changes are reflected in paleopathology.
Bremner, Maurice David Kaufman, The story of dentistry : from the dawn of civilization to the present
with special emphasis on the American scene : Ann Arbor, MI : Xeror University Microfilms, 1975.
Brothwell. D. Animal diseases in archaeology/ J. Baker D. Brothwell London ; Toronto : Academic Press,
Frayer, David W. The evolution of the dentition in upper paleolithic and mesolithic
Europe. Lawrence : University of Kansas, 1989.
Hillson, S. Dental Anthropology. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1996.
Larsen, C. Bioarchaeology Interpreting Behavior from the Human Skeleton. New York: Cambridge
University Press, 1999.
Larson, Shavit, Griffen. Dental Caries, Evidence for Dietary Change: Advances in Dental Anthropology
Editors Kelley, Spencer: Wiley-Liss Perss, New York 1990.
Prinz, Hermann, Dental chronology : a record of the more important historic events in the evolution of
Dentistry: Ann Arbor, MI : Xerox University Microfilms, 1975
Mays. Glen P. Managed care and public health / [edited by] Paul K. Halverson, Arnold D. Kaluzny, Curtis
P. McLaughlin Managed care and public health Gaithersburg, MD : Aspen Publication, 1998
Alt., Rosing, F., and Teschler-Nicola, M. eds Dental Anthropology Fundamentals Limits and
Prospects. New York: SpringerWien, 1998.
Rose, J. et al “Diet and Dentition: Developmental Disturbances” in The Analysis of Prehistoric Diets.
New York: Academic Press, 1985.
Schour, Isaac. Atlas of the mouth in health and disease. 2nd ed Chicago : American Dental Association,
Shafer, William G. A textbook of oral pathology 4th ed. Philadelphia : Saunders, 1983.
Shaw, Evelyn S. Oral incubation in Tilapia macrocephala. New York : [American Museum of Natural